Following up
7 May 09

In a previous life I juggled a role that was equal parts information architecture and knowledge management. The fields are closer than you may think, both revolving around codifying, transferring and assimilating information.
Knowledge managers strive for the ‘watercooler moment’, where a colleague mentions in passing something that saves you weeks of work. There’s plenty of thought on how to engender this culture – even interior design has a role – but it can only ever come about by getting people talking. Sometimes, particularly in a fledgling community, this can be achieved via a social object.
My post last week (“Complex inferiority – user experience in the UK”) certainly generated the discussion I hoped for, with opinion split on whether I had a valid point and even whether my points were helpful or harmful. To that end it served its purpose, but I would like to clarify a couple of points.
I am not writing off the UK user experience scene. Far from it. I see UX as my calling, not just my career, and I’ll work as hard as I can to help it thrive here. And we are clearly on an exciting upward swing. However, I’m convinced that we need to be honest about where we must improve, and until we have (amongst other things) widespread mentoring, closer ties between academia and industry, more vocal discussion and a body of excellent work I will always see room for improvement.
Let me also be clear that I don’t advocate empty self-promotion. We don’t need rockstars. We need excellent people contributing to the community. My definition of a leader is someone who goes first, and encourages others to follow. Obviously I hope to contribute in whatever small way I can, but I urge anyone who cares about this scene to take the reins and try out new things to help our nascent community.
3 comments on Following up
Mentoring is something I’m interested in pursuing at FP; we’re trying to do this right now for folks in some areas of our business (QA)… but it feels like something that’d be really useful for specialists from any discipline who might otherwise be “outnumbered” in an organisation. Are you aware of any schemes or communities to support this sort of thing in UX?
And +1 to closer ties between academia and industry. I’ve had a long-standing suspicion of academia gently beaten out of me over the last few years, and a good thing too – there’s lots of good stuff out there. Sussex in particular has some good HCI folks, is encouraging stronger links with the local community through the likes of the Innovation Centre and events like Enterprising Engineers, and has some interesting stuff going on with games and usability:
http://ianozsvald.com/2009/04/14/informatics-update-graham-mcallister-and-video-game-usability-invited-post/
So, any other suggestions for how we get these links built?
Hi Tom,
In an ideal world I’m of the belief that a company shouldn’t need to institute a mentoring programme, since it’s something a line manager should do by default. However, as rightly you point out, many people aren’t lucky as to have a line manager of equal or greater specialised skill, so most will have to look farther afield.
The only UX mentoring programme I’m aware of is through the IA Institute, which obviously requires potential proteges to be members. It’s a good scheme and the IAI offers good support to mentors, but it might not suit everyone. I don’t know if, for instance, the IxDA has plans to introduce a similar programme, but it the best scheme may prove to be one without political affiliation. I’d love to see one set up, which of course gets me thinking about what might be involved…
I think a few people have misread my attitude toward academia. I have a science background myself and have learned a great deal from universities and research (it was de Groot’s studies on cognitive psychology in chess that got me interested in the field), but I do think it’s failing to meet our employment needs and should be doing more to contribute directly enough to practice (although that is of course a two-way street).
In answer to your question, I don’t know where else to start but talking to people. So that’s what I hope to do, and what caused me to state my case in the hope that others will join the dialogue. Hopefully we’ll stumble across a productive solution in the process.
The IXDA have recently published some info on mentoring schemes here:
http://www.ixda.org/download/ixda_mentorship_01.pdf
Add a comment